PolitiMeterLatest coverage
STATE WATCH · Alabama · 3 SOURCES

Supreme Court Redistricting Ruling Prompts State-Level Responses in Alabama, Louisiana

Supreme Court Redistricting Ruling Prompts State-Level Responses in Alabama, Louisiana
Source image: Fox News

Following a U.S. Supreme Court ruling on Louisiana's congressional map that altered legal standards under the Voting Rights Act, several states took redistricting-related actions. Reports vary in scope: NBC News and WHNT focused on Alabama and Tennessee's legislative responses, while Fox News covered a Louisiana congressman's decision to leave Congress amid district changes stemming from the ruling.

LEFT 0%CENTER 67%RIGHT 33%
JUST THE FACTS

The U.S. Supreme Court issued a ruling in Louisiana v. Callais addressing race and redistricting, which multiple outlets reported altered legal protections under Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act related to racial gerrymandering claims. In response, the Republican governors of Alabama and Tennessee called special legislative sessions to consider new congressional maps, according to NBC News and WHNT. Separately, Fox News reported that Louisiana Democratic Rep. Cleo Fields plans to leave Congress and return to the Louisiana state Senate after the ruling altered the boundaries of his 6th Congressional District. In Alabama, the special legislative session concluded with Governor Kay Ivey signing House Bill 1 and Senate Bill 1, according to WHNT. These bills establish a contingency process allowing the state's scheduled May 19 primary to proceed under existing congressional maps, but they provide that if court injunctions on those maps are lifted or the maps are changed, the primary results could be invalidated and special primary elections called in the affected districts. NBC News did not report the specific contents of the Alabama legislation, focusing instead on the initial calling of the special session by Alabama's and Tennessee's governors following the Supreme Court decision. As of the reporting, it remains unresolved what specific new congressional maps, if any, will be adopted in Alabama or Tennessee as a result of their special sessions, and whether litigation over existing maps will lead to injunctions being lifted, which would trigger the contingency special elections described in the Alabama legislation. It is also unclear whether Rep. Fields' departure is directly tied to a finalized redrawn map or anticipated changes still subject to legal proceedings. No outlet provided details on the Tennessee special session's legislative outcomes or timeline for map changes.

SOURCE COMPARISON

How the coverage differs

Fox NewsRight framing

'Jumping ship': House Dem finds exit strategy after SCOTUS ruling shifts advantage to GOP

Rep Cleo Fields, D-La., will leave Congress to return to the Louisiana state Senate after the Supreme Court's ruling in Louisiana v. Callais reshaped his 6th Congressional District.

Read original report ↗
WHNTCenter framing

Alabama governor signs special election bills as special legislative session concludes

Alabama Governor Kay Ivey signed House Bill 1 and Senate Bill 1, passed during a special session, that could trigger special elections if the state's congressional maps change. The plan would let the May 19 primary proceed as scheduled but invalidate results and call special primaries in certain districts if court injunctions on the maps are lifted.

Read original report ↗
NBC NewsCenter framing

Alabama and Tennessee set special sessions to consider new congressional maps after Supreme Court ruling

The Republican governors of Alabama and Tennessee called for special legislative sessions to consider new congressional maps after a Supreme Court decision on race and redistricting. The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that Louisiana's congressional map was unconstitutional, in an opinion effectively gutting racial gerrymandering protections in Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act.

Read original report ↗